This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.
I’ll be honest — when I bought Nuggy’s first lick mat, I used it for exactly one thing: peanut butter. Every single time. It took me embarrassingly long to realize that the mat wasn’t boring — I was.
The fix turned out to be simple. Here are 15 lick mat recipes for dogs that we’ve actually tested in our kitchen — everyday spreads, frozen summer versions, calming bedtime combos, and a few puppy-safe ideas. All of them use ingredients you probably have right now, and none of them take more than five minutes.
Why bother? Licking is naturally soothing for dogs — it releases endorphins and gives busy brains a job. Ten minutes on a lick mat can take the edge off a thunderstorm, a nail trim, or that witching hour when your dog decides the couch cushions look delicious.
What You’ll Need
Just two things, really:
- A textured lick mat — we use the MateeyLife Lick Mat 2-pack with suction cups. The suction matters more than you’d think: it sticks to the fridge door, the bathtub during baths, or the floor without sliding into the wall.
- Dog-safe peanut butter — several recipes below call for it. We keep Buddy Budder around because it’s made specifically for dogs, so there’s no label-checking anxiety. If you use regular PB, it must be xylitol-free — more on that in our peanut butter safety guide
Quick Tips Before You Start
- Spread thin. A lick mat is about licking time, not volume. One to two tablespoons of topping is plenty for most dogs.
- Freeze for longer sessions. Pop the loaded mat in the freezer for 1–2 hours and a 5-minute snack becomes a 20-minute project.
- Count it as food. Lick mat toppings are treats — keep them under 10% of your dog’s daily calories, and scale meal portions down on lick mat days.
- Introduce it easy. First time? Use something irresistible (peanut butter wins) and don’t freeze it yet. Let your dog succeed fast.
- Cleanup: most silicone mats are dishwasher safe, top rack. Ours goes in with every load.
Everyday Lick Mat Recipes
These five are our weekday rotation — no prep, no blender, straight from the fridge.
1. Classic Peanut Butter & Banana
Mash half a ripe banana with a spoonful of dog-safe peanut butter and spread it on. This is the recipe that made Nuggy fall in love with his mat — he demolishes it in minutes, then keeps licking the empty mat out of pure hope. Storage: use immediately or freeze; mashed banana browns fast.
2. Greek Yogurt & Blueberries
Plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt, plus a small handful of blueberries pressed into the surface. Yogurt brings probiotics; blueberries bring antioxidants and something to chase around the grooves. Make it easier: stir the berries in whole — no need to smash them.
3. Pumpkin & Yogurt Swirl
Equal parts pure pumpkin purée (not pie filling — that has spices and sugar) and plain yogurt, swirled together. Pumpkin is gentle on digestion, which makes this our go-to after a slightly-too-adventurous walk. Storage: leftover canned pumpkin freezes beautifully in ice cube trays.
4. Apple & Peanut Butter Crunch
Grate a quarter of an apple (skip the core and seeds), mix into a spoonful of peanut butter. The texture keeps dogs working longer than smooth spreads. If your dog is a peanut butter fanatic, our 9 homemade peanut butter treat recipes are the logical next step.
5. Mashed Sweet Potato
Leftover plain cooked sweet potato, mashed and spread. No salt, no butter, no seasoning. Naturally sweet, full of fiber, and one of the cheapest options on this list. Make it easier: microwave a small sweet potato for 4–5 minutes instead of baking.
Frozen Lick Mat Recipes for Hot Days
Summer versions — load, freeze, serve outside. These pair well with the ideas in our 10 homemade frozen dog treatsroundup.
6. Frozen Watermelon Smash
Mash seedless watermelon flesh, mix with a spoonful of plain yogurt so it holds, spread, and freeze for 2 hours. Watermelon is over 90% water — hydration disguised as a treat.
7. Bone Broth Ice Glaze
Pour a thin layer of cooled dog-safe bone broth (low sodium, absolutely no onion or garlic) over the mat and freeze flat. It turns the mat into a savory ice lolly. Storage: frozen loaded mats keep 2–3 days wrapped in the freezer.
8. Frozen Banana “Ice Cream”
Blend one frozen banana until creamy — that’s it, one-ingredient ice cream. Spread and refreeze for 30 minutes. Nuggy rates this one 5 paws out of 5, and he is not an easy critic.
9. Strawberry Yogurt Freeze
Three or four chopped strawberries stirred into plain yogurt, spread and frozen. Pretty enough that someone in your house will ask if it’s for them. It is not.
Calming Lick Mat Recipes for Bedtime
The lick-to-calm-down effect is real at our house — these three are for storm nights, post-zoomies wind-down, and dogs who struggle to settle. If evenings are your dog’s hard time in general, a lick mat works even better alongside the routine from our calm cozy toys guide.
10. Chamomile Oat Mash
Brew chamomile tea, let it cool completely, and stir a few tablespoons into quick oats until it forms a soft paste. Chamomile is a classic gentle calmer for dogs — the same reason our bedtime biscuits use it. Make it easier: use warm (not hot) water instead of tea; the oats alone still do the slow-licking job.
11. Cottage Cheese & Pumpkin
Low-fat cottage cheese mixed with a spoonful of pumpkin purée. Mild, protein-rich, and easy on sensitive stomachs before sleep. Skip this one if your dog doesn’t handle dairy well.
12. Warm Oatmeal & Peanut Butter
Plain cooked oatmeal (cooled to room temperature) with a thin ribbon of peanut butter through it. Comfort food, dog edition. Storage: make a small batch of plain oatmeal and refrigerate — it loads three mats over three evenings.
Puppy Lick Mat Ideas
Puppies can use lick mats too — smaller portions, softer textures, and nothing frozen solid for baby teeth. These three puppy lick mat ideas are where we’d start:
13. Soaked Kibble Mash
Soak a small portion of your puppy’s own kibble in warm water until soft, mash, and spread. Zero new ingredients means zero tummy risk — perfect first mat experience.
14. Thin Yogurt Spread
A teaspoon or two of plain unsweetened yogurt, spread paper-thin. Enough to teach “licking the mat is great” without overloading a small stomach.
15. Pumpkin & Kibble Swirl
Mashed soaked kibble swirled with a teaspoon of pumpkin purée. A gentle upgrade once plain kibble mash is old news. Pro tip: a lick mat during handling practice (paws, ears, brushing) builds a puppy who tolerates grooming for life.
What Never to Put on a Lick Mat
The short list that matters — keep these away from the mat and the dog:
- Xylitol (in many “sugar-free” peanut butters, yogurts, and puddings) — extremely toxic to dogs, even in small amounts
- Grapes and raisins — can cause kidney failure
- Chocolate and cocoa in any form
- Onion and garlic — including broths and baby foods that contain them; always read broth labels
- Macadamia nuts
- Added sugar, salt, and artificial sweeteners generally — your dog doesn’t need them and won’t miss them
When in doubt, keep it boring: single ingredients you’d recognize in a kitchen, plain versions only.
The Takeaway
Fifteen recipes sounds like a lot, but the real system is simple: one base (yogurt, pumpkin, peanut butter, or mashed banana), one mix-in, freeze it if you want it to last. Rotate through the list and your dog gets variety while you spend five minutes a week on it.
Nuggy’s current ranking, for the record: frozen banana ice cream first, PB & banana a close second, and honestly everything else tied for “also acceptable, please hurry up.”
Which one does your dog go crazy for? And if licking turns out to be your dog’s love language, our 12 easy enrichment ideas that actually calm your dog has ten more ways to put that busy tongue and brain to work.